ISTANBUL TECHNICAL UNIVERSITY  GRADUATE SCHOOL M.Sc. THESIS JANUARY 2023 UML MODELLING OF DISASTER MANAGEMENT DATA ACCORDING TO TUCBS DATA DEFINITION GUIDE: ISTANBUL EXAMPLE Özge USAL Department of Geomatics Engineering Geomatics Engineering Programme JANUARY 2023 ISTANBUL TECHNICAL UNIVERSITY  GRADUATE SCHOOL UML MODELLING OF DISASTER MANAGEMENT DATA ACCORDING TO TUCBS DATA DEFINITION GUIDE: ISTANBUL EXAMPLE M.Sc. THESIS Özge USAL (501191637) Thesis Advisor: Associate Prof. Dr. Turan ERDEN Department of Geomatics Engineering Geomatics Engineering Programme Geomatik Mühendisliği Anabilim Dalı Geomatik Mühendisliği Programı OCAK 2023 İSTANBUL TEKNİK ÜNİVERSİTESİ  LİSANSÜSTÜ EĞİTİM ENSTİTÜSÜ TUCBS VERİ TANIMLAMA KILAVUZUNA GÖRE AFET YÖNETİMİ VERİLERİNİN UML İLE MODELLENMESİ: İSTANBUL ÖRNEĞİ YÜKSEK LİSANS TEZİ Özge USAL (501191637) Tez Danışmanı: Doç. Dr. Turan ERDEN v Thesis Advisor: Associate Prof. Dr. Turan ERDEN .............................. Istanbul Technical University Jury Members: Prof. Dr. Himmet KARAMAN .............................. Istanbul Technical University Jury Members: Prof. Dr. Arif Çağdaş AYDINOĞLU .............................. Gebze Technical University Özge USAL, a M.Sc. student of ITU Graduate School student ID 501191637 successfully defended the thesis/dissertation entitled “UML MODELLING OF DISASTER MANAGEMENT DATA ACCORDING TO TUCBS DATA DEFINITION GUIDE: ISTANBUL EXAMPLE”, which she prepared after fulfilling the requirements specified in the associated legislations, before the jury whose signatures are below. Date of Submission : 29 December 2022 Date of Defense : 30 January 2023 vi vii To my family and my loved ones, viii ix FOREWORD I would like to express my deepest gratitude to my advisors Associate Prof. Dr. Turan ERDEN and Prof. Dr. Himmet KARAMAN, for their invaluable guidance and gracious support throughout my MSc journey. For their valuable contributions to my life, I am grateful to all members of the Geomatics Engineering Department. I thank my parents and sisters for encouraging me throughout my academic career. Lastly, I would like to thank my spouse Deniz USAL for everything that he brought to my life as well as his support in this study. December 2022 Özge USAL (Geomatics Engineer) x xi TABLE OF CONTENTS Page FOREWORD ......................................................................................................... ix TABLE OF CONTENTS ......................................................................................... xi ABBREVIATIONS ................................................................................................. xiii LIST OF TABLES ................................................................................................... xv LIST OF FIGURES ............................................................................................... xvii SUMMARY ....................................................................................................... xix ÖZET ....................................................................................................... xxi 1. INTRODUCTION .................................................................................................. 1 1.1 Purpose of Thesis ............................................................................................... 2 1.2 Method .......................................................................................................... 3 2. GENERAL INFORMATIONS ............................................................................. 5 2.1 Geographical Information Systems .................................................................... 5 2.1.1 GIS components .......................................................................................... 5 2.1.2 Data models for GIS .................................................................................... 6 2.1.3 GIS process ................................................................................................. 7 2.1.3.1 Data capture .......................................................................................... 7 2.1.3.2 Data manipulation ................................................................................ 7 2.1.3.3 Data management ................................................................................. 8 2.1.3.4 Query & analyze ................................................................................... 8 2.1.3.5 Visualization ......................................................................................... 8 2.2 Disaster and Disaster Management .................................................................... 8 2.2.1 Disaster ........................................................................................................ 8 2.2.1.1 Factor causing disaster ......................................................................... 9 2.2.1.2 Disaster types..................................................................................... 10 2.2.1.2.1 Natural disasters .......................................................................... 10 2.2.1.2.2 Unnatural disasters ...................................................................... 10 2.2.1.2.3 Complex disasters ....................................................................... 10 2.2.2 Disaster management ................................................................................ 12 2.2.2.1 Phases of disaster management and the disaster cycle ....................... 16 2.3 GIS and Disaster Management ......................................................................... 18 2.3.1 Development of GIS.................................................................................. 18 2.3.2 GIS and Disaster Management .................................................................. 19 2.4 GIS Standards ................................................................................................... 21 2.4.1 INSPIRE .................................................................................................... 21 2.4.2 Turkish National Geographical Information System (TUCBS) ................ 21 2.4.3 OGC (Open Geospatial Consortium) ........................................................ 22 2.5 Databases ........................................................................................................ 23 2.5.1 Database model ......................................................................................... 23 2.5.2 Geographical databases ............................................................................. 24 xii 2.6 Development of TUCBS .................................................................................. 25 2.7 TUCBS Geodata Themes ................................................................................. 29 2.7.1 TUCBS Natural risk zones theme ............................................................. 33 2.7.1.1 “TehlikeAlani” Hazard Area .............................................................. 34 2.7.1.2 “TehlikeAltindakiVarlik” (ExposedElement) .................................... 35 2.7.2 “RiskBolgesi” (RiskZone) ......................................................................... 36 2.7.3 “GozlenenOlay” (ObservedEvent) ............................................................ 37 2.8 Unified Modelling Language/UML .................................................................. 38 2.8.1 UML Relation Types ................................................................................. 39 2.8.1.1 Association ......................................................................................... 39 2.8.1.2 Inheritance .......................................................................................... 40 2.8.1.3 Aggregation ........................................................................................ 41 2.8.1.4 Composition ....................................................................................... 42 2.8.2 Data Modelling with UML ........................................................................ 42 2.9 Geography Markup Language/GML ................................................................ 43 2.10 Hale Studio ..................................................................................................... 45 3. STUDY ........................................................................................................ 47 3.1 Study Area ........................................................................................................ 47 3.2 Data Definition ................................................................................................. 48 3.3 Data Transformation ......................................................................................... 49 3.4 Data Sharing ..................................................................................................... 56 4. CONCLUSION AND SUGGESTIONS .............................................................. 59 REFERENCES ........................................................................................................ 63 APPENDICES ........................................................................................................ 67 CURRICULUM VITAE .......................................................................................... 73 xiii ABBREVIATIONS AI : Artificial Intelligence CBS : Coğrafi Bilgi Sistemleri CRS : Coordinate Transformation Service CS/W : Catalog for the Web DBMS : Database Management System ER : Entity Relationships HGK : Harita Genel Komutanlığı ITRF : International Terrestrial Reference Frame GIS : Geographical Information Systems GML : Geography Markup Language INSPIRE : Infrastructure for Spatial Information in the European Community ISO : Iternational Organization for Standardization KBS : Urban Information System (Kent Bilgi Sistemi) OGC : Open Geospatial Consortium SDI : Spatial Data Infrastructure SQL : Structured Query Language TRKBIS : Türkiye Urban Information System Standards (Türkiye Kent Bilgi Sistemleri Standartları) TUCBS : Turkish National Geograpic Information System (Türkiye Ulusal Cografi Bilgi Sistemi) TUREF : Projected coordinate system for Türkiye UML : Unified Modeling Language UTM : Universal Transverse Mercator WCS : Web Coverage Service WFS : Web Feature Service WMO : World Meteorological Organization WMS : Web Map Service XML : Extensible Markup Language xiv xv LIST OF TABLES Page Table 2. 1 : Geographical Data Themes .................................................................... 31 Table 2. 2 : Sub-theme groups (category information). ............................................ 32 Table 2. 3 : A GML instance document “exampleRoad.xml”. ................................. 45 Table 3. 1 : Study data analysis. ................................................................................ 48 Table 3. 2 : Study data attributes ............................................................................... 49 Table 3. 3 : Assigned code values. ............................................................................ 54 Table 3. 4 : HazardArea and RiskZone data sizes..................................................... 55 xvi xvii LIST OF FIGURES Page Figure 2. 1 : Vector Data Models. ............................................................................... 7 Figure 2. 2 : Disaster Management Cycle. ................................................................ 17 Figure 2. 3 : UML and ER diagrams. (Aydinoglu, 2009) ......................................... 24 Figure 2. 4 : OGC geometry object model (OGC, 1999; Aydinoglu, 2009) ............ 25 Figure 2. 5 : TUCBS standard hierarchy. (CBSGM, 2012a) .................................... 27 Figure 2. 6 : TRKBIS Project work packages. .......................................................... 28 Figure 2. 7 : Hierarchical structure for modeling Geographical data in Geographical data themes. .......................................................................................... 30 Figure 2. 8 : UML Scheme of Natural Risk Zones. .................................................. 34 Figure 2. 9 : UML Class Diagram: DogalRiskBolgeleri code lists. ......................... 37 Figure 2. 10 : UML Relation Types - Association. ................................................... 40 Figure 2. 11 : UML multiplicity indicators. (Ambler, 2002) .................................... 40 Figure 2. 12 : UML Relation Types - Inheritance (Generalization). ........................ 41 Figure 2. 13 : UML Relation Types – Aggregation. (Url-9)..................................... 41 Figure 2. 14 : UML Relation Types – Composition. (Url-9) .................................... 42 Figure 2. 15 : UML Relation Types – Association, Aggregation, and Composition. (Url-9) ................................................................................................... 42 Figure 2. 16 : Hale Studio overview. ........................................................................ 46 Figure 2. 17 : Goals of HUMBOLDT European projec ........................................... 46 Figure 3. 1 : Location of Umraniye........................................................................... 47 Figure 3. 2 : Source and target schemas overview. Hale studio. .............................. 50 Figure 3. 3 : Definition of id target column from source schema in Hale Studio. .... 51 Figure 3. 4 : Assigning of dogalTehlikeKategorisi code list in Hale Studio. ........... 51 Figure 3. 5 : Transformation process mapping for erosion data. .............................. 52 Figure 3. 6 : Reprojection of transformed data. ........................................................ 52 Figure 3. 7 : Transformation process mapping for landslide data. ........................... 52 Figure 3. 8 : Transformation process mapping for liquefaction data. ....................... 53 Figure 3. 9 : Transformation process mapping for flood data. ................................. 53 Figure 3. 10 : Transformation process mapping for overflowing data. .................... 53 Figure 3. 11 : Transformation process mapping for risky parcels data..................... 53 Figure 3. 12 : Transformation process mapping for risky buildings data. ................ 54 Figure 3. 13 : The sizes of transformed data sets. ..................................................... 54 Figure 3. 14 : Displaying of result TehlikeAlani data in QGIS desktop software. ... 56 Figure 3. 15 : Adding data in Geoserver software for sharing. ................................. 57 Figure 3. 16 : Displaying of result RiskBolgesi data in Geoserver as OpenLayers map. ....................................................................................................... 57 Figure 3. 17 : Displaying of result WFS service in QGIS desktop. .......................... 57 xviii xix UML MODELLING OF DIASTER MANAGEMENT DATA ACCORDING TO TUCBS DATA DEFINITION GUIDE: ISTANBUL EXAMPLE SUMMARY Various types of disaster occur worldwide and in Türkiye each year due to physical and human factors. In recent years, disasters have grown increasingly complex as a result of global climate change and human factors, whose mechanisms are difficult to understand. As a result, many lives and properties have been lost. Collaboration and coordination among institutions and organizations play a significant role in disaster mitigation. For institutions working on disasters to effectively intervene, they need to have adequate information and data. Coordination is the ability of all institutions to act in a coordinated manner. It is therefore possible to minimize the adverse effects of disasters in this manner. Disaster management studies are conducted by a number of institutions and organizations in Türkiye. Production, storage, and update of disaster data sets require the use of a standard methodology. Once data has been generated, it must be able to be utilized and shared correctly. Geographical data is used by a variety of institutions and organizations to meet the needs of these parties to the maximum of their abilities. Therefore, it is recommended that different institutions and organizations do not produce the same data repeatedly. Given that the risk zones geographical data are being used by more than one institution, these datasets should adhere to the same standards. During the development of Turkish National Geographical Information Systems (TUCBS) infrastructure standards, natural risk areas were examined within the scope of the thesis. These standards are being developed in accordance with ISO/TC211 standards for the development of a geographical data model. They are also being developed according to those of the Open Geographical Information Consortium for the exchange of web services and geographical information. Data related to natural risk zones have been examined. Using the risk data of Istanbul province, Umraniye county, the data transformation process was carried out. Thus, it is possible to ensure compatibility with the TUCBS Natural Risk Zones data theme. xx xxi TUCBS VERİ TANIMLAMA KILAVUZUNA GÖRE AFET YÖNETİMİ VERİLERİNİN UML İLE MODELLENMESİ: İSTANBUL ÖRNEĞİ ÖZET Dünyada ve Türkiye'de her yıl fiziksel ve beşeri faktörler nedeniyle çeşitli türlerde afetler meydana gelmektedir. Afetler, küresel iklim değişikliği ve mekanizmaları, anlaşılması güç olan insan faktörleri nedeniyle giderek daha karmaşık hale gelmektedir. Bunun sonucunda çok sayıda can ve mal kaybı olmuştur. Kurum ve kuruluşlar arasındaki işbirliği ve koordinasyon, afetlerin azaltılmasında önemli rol oynamaktadır. Afetlerle ilgili çalışan kurumların etkin bir şekilde müdahale edebilmeleri için yeterli bilgi ve veriye sahip olmaları gerekmektedir. Koordinasyon, tüm kurumların koordineli bir şekilde hareket edebilmesidir. Dolayısıyla afetlerin olumsuz etkilerini bu şekilde en aza indirmek mümkündür. Afet yönetimi çalışmaları Türkiye'de birçok kurum ve kuruluş tarafından yürütülmektedir. Afet verilerinin üretilmesi, saklanması ve güncellenmesi için standart bir yöntem belirlenmelidir. Verilerin çeşitli çalışmalara katkıda bulunabilmesi için, oluşturulduktan sonra doğru bir şekilde kullanılabilmesi ve paylaşılabilmesi gerekir. Coğrafi veriler, çeşitli kurum ve kuruluşlar tarafından bu tarafların ihtiyaçlarını ellerinden geldiğince karşılamak amacıyla kullanılmaktadır. Bu nedenle farklı kurum ve kuruluşların aynı verileri tekrar tekrar üretmemeleri önerilir. Doğal afet coğrafi verilerinin birden fazla kurum tarafından kullanıldığı düşünüldüğünde, bu veri setlerinin aynı standartlara sahip olması gerekmektedir. Türkiye Ulusal Coğrafi Bilgi Sistemi (TUCBS) altyapısının tesisi ve coğrafi verinin ulusal düzeyde üretimi ile paylaşımına yönelik standartların belirlenmesi görevleri Çevre ve Şehircilik Bakanlığı bünyesinde Coğrafi Bilgi Sistemleri Genel Müdürlüğü'ne verilmiştir. Bu kapsamda Coğrafi Bilgi Sistemleri Genel Müdürlüğü tarafından 2013 yılında 10 adet ulusal coğrafi veri temasına ilişkin standartlar belirlenmiştir. Ancak bahsi geçen standartların zamanla değişen güncel ihtiyaçları karşılamamasından dolayı standartların güncellemesine ve genişletilmesine ihtiyaç duyulmuştur. Bu sebeple paydaş kamu kurumlarının katılımı ile 2018’de gerçekleştirilen toplantılarda önceden belirlenen standartlar güncellenmiştir. Coğrafi Bilgi Sistemleri Genel Müdürlüğü’nün standart belirleme çalışmaları kapsamında 2019 yılında 8 yeni veri teması için de veri tanımlama dokümanları hazırlanmıştır. OGC (OPEN Geospatial Consortium), açık web jeo-uzamsal standartları geliştirmek için çalışan birkaç şirket, devlet kurumu ve üniversiteden oluşan uluslararası bir konsorsiyumdur. OGC Standartları mekansal veri paylaşımını web tabanlı servisler üzerinden yapar. Karmaşık yöntemlerle üretilen ya da paylaşılan mekânsal veriler, herkes için kolay bir şekilde kullanılabilir. xxii OGC, ISO/TC211 komitesi ile paralel çalışmalar yürütmekte ve hazırlanan standartlar ile daha uygun çözümler sunmaktadır. Web Map servis, web haritalarını paylaşmak için bir OGC standartıdır. WMS sayesinde kullanıcılar, OGC uyumlu istemci uygulamaları aracılığıyla stilize edilmiş web haritalarına ulaşabilirler. Mekansal veri; Oracle Server, Microsoft SQL Server veya PostgreSQL Server gibi ilişkisel veritabanlarinda saklananabilmektedir. Böylece web servislerinde görüntülenmek üzere yayınlanabilmektedir. Web Feature Servis (WFS), mekansal verileri paylaşmak için bir OGC standartıdır. WMS'den farklı olarak, kullanıcılar ilişkisel veri tabanı sisteminde depolanan mekansal verilere OGC uyumlu istemci uygulaması üzerinden doğrudan erişebilirler. Bu nedenle WFS, mekansal verileri analiz etmek için daha uygundur. Web Coverage Servis (WCS), kapsama verilerini paylaşmak için bir OGC standartıdır. WFS'den farklı olarak, WCS jeo uzamsal raster veri paylaşım kurallarını açıklar. Özellikle uzaktan algılama verileri uydu imgeleri, orto rektifiyeli fotoğraflar gibi WCS de raster verileri analiz etmek için uygundur. GML, mekansal verileri depolamak için XML tabanlı bir OGC standartıdır. GML, özel xml uygulama şeması aracılığıyla konuma bağlı grafiksel ve grafiksel olmayan verileri depolayabilir. GML'nin faydaları, platformlar arası ve kolay anlaşılır dosya formatıdır. WFS gibi konum tabanlı web hizmetleri de mekansal verileri paylaşmak için GML formatını kullanır. Uzamsal verilerin oluşturulması, yönetilmesi, saklanması ve güncellenmesi için takip edilmesi gereken standart bir yöntem gereklidir. Verinin değerli olması, doğru kullanılmasına ve paylaşılabilir olmasına bağlıdır. Verilerin farklı kuruluşlarda farklı kullanıcılar tarafından kullanılması, optimum kullanıcı ihtiyaçlarını karşılaması ile ilgilidir. Aynı veriler farklı kuruluşlar tarafından tekrar tekrar oluşturuluyorsa verilerin çoğaltılması verilerin güncelliğini kaybetmesine neden olur. Tez kapsamında Türkiye Ulusal Coğrafi Bilgi Sistemleri (TUCBS) altyapı standartlarının geliştirilmesi sürecinde doğal risk alanları teması incelenmiştir. Bu standartlar, coğrafi veri modelinin geliştirilmesi için ISO/TC211 standartlarına uygun olarak geliştirilmektedir. Ayrıca, web hizmetleri ve coğrafi bilgi alışverişi için Açık Coğrafi Bilgi Konsorsiyumu'na göre geliştirilmektedirler. Doğal risk bölgeleri veri teması incelenmiştir. İstanbul ili Ümraniye ilçesi risk verileri kullanılarak veri dönüştürme işlemi gerçekleştirilmiştir. Böylece TUCBS Doğal Risk Bölgeleri veri teması ile uyumluluğun sağlanması mümkün olmuştur. Tezin uygulama bölümleri için TUCBS doğal risk bölgeleri veri standardı kullanılarak doğal afet verileri GML veri setlerine dönüştürülmüştür. Dönüşüm işlemi Hale Studio Masaüstü Yazilimi kullanılmıştır. Açık kaynaklı ETL aracı olan Hale studio ilk olarak 2006 yılında HUMBOLDT Avrupa entegre projesi kapsamında geliştirilmiştir. Bu proje, mekansal verilerin ülkeler arası uyumlaştırılmasını kolaylaştırmaya ve desteklemeye odaklanmıştır. Hale Studio kullanılarak Istanbul ile Ümraniye ilçesine ait olan heyelan, erozyon, taşkın, su baskını, sıvılaşma, riskli parsel ve riskli yapılar verileri ilk olarak incelenerek veri şemasina uyumlu olabilecek alanların tespiti yapılmıştır. Ardından TUCBS Doğal Risk Bölgeleri Veri Temasına uygun olacak şekilde transformasyon işlemi gerçekleştirilmiştir. Sonuç veriler GML formatında kaydedilmiştir. Üretilen veri setleri QGIS açık kaynaklı GIS yazılımı kullanılarak görüntülenmiştir. Sonuc veriler TehlikeAlani ve RiskliBolgeleri olarak iki farklı katmanda TUCBS veri temasına uygun olarak QGIS kullanılarak birleştirilerek PostgreSQL veri tabanına kaydedilmiştir. xxiii Verilerin WMS ve WFS formatında yayınlanbilmesi icin Geoserver aracılıgı ile WMS ve WFS formatında paylasımı yapılmıstır. GeoServer, kullanıcıların jeo-uzamsal verileri paylaşmasına, işlemesine ve düzenlemesine olanak tanıyan, Java ile yazılmış açık kaynaklı bir sunucudur. Birlikte çalışabilirlik için tasarlanmıştir. xxiv 1 1. INTRODUCTION Geographical Information Systems (GIS) is an information system in which geographical data and feature data can be integrated meaningfully in modeling the real world, providing decision support with spatial analysis, and presenting them to the user. The five essential components of GIS are software, hardware, people, methods, and data (Yomralıoğlu, 2000). Data is crucial for GIS. Because of that, the creation of geographical data with metadata and GIS standards is vital. Providing a standard and keeping updated on geographical data provide multiple usages of geographical data in different applications and services. The main of the interoperability of data is predetermined data creation standards and usage standards. The primary purposes of standardization; can be listed as preventing time and cost loss, ensuring effective use of information, preventing information loss, facilitating information transfer, and increasing quality. Standard development studies are carried out by many national or international organizations in the world (ISO/TC211, 2011; OGC,2013; CBSGM, 2012; Aydinoglu, 2009). Geographical Information constitutes approximately 80% of all Information and is considered adequate in 90% of decision-making mechanisms (Aydinoglu, 2009; Yomralıoğlu, 2000). Geographical Information has social importance because of its benefits to citizens and public and private sectors by providing the basis for country policies and decision-making mechanisms. For using data on local, regional, and national, international scales, Integration is essential to prevent loss of Information due to time and effort waste by contributing to decision-making in the use of geographical data. This approach has resulted in the concept of Geographical /Spatial Data Infrastructure that defines the interoperability of geographical data (Aydinoglu, 2009). The INSPIRE Directive was adopted and entered into force by the European Parliament. The relevant application rules can be accepted as a framework for establishing National Geographical / Spatial Data Infrastructures by member states for environmental activities (Url-1). 2 Since 2004, actions for establishing Turkish National GIS have been carried out for the interoperability of geographical data at the national level. Data standards for basic Geographical data themes are developed by the GIS General Directorate, established in 2011, and legal and technical components are determined for data sharing with GIS Portals in the web environment. GIS has an active role in disaster management studies. Accessibility to services is important for emergency activities during and after a disaster. Coordination of interoperability provides quick and cost-effective service delivery. (Tastan, 2021; Mutlu & Bank, 2011). One of INSPIRE' s 34 data themes was developed against natural hazards. The change in information technologies has increased the use of GIS in disaster management. Up-to-date Information is critical in disaster-emergency studies Obtaining up-to-date data and accessing dispersed Information quickly are essential for effective interventions after a disaster. For disaster management, timely access to the Information of critical resources is the most basic requirement. The production and use of data in a common standard will facilitate interoperability. In addition to simplifying the integrated management of data, allowing different institutions and organizations to utilize this data more easily, we will also be able to prevent the duplication of geographical data sets, produce them following national standards, and use them with open data services (Tastan, 2021; Erhan, 2013; Bilgin, 2013). Therefore, institutions and organizations can conduct disaster risk studies more efficiently. Data can be transferred and manipulated more easily. 1.1 Purpose of Thesis The geographical data controller needs to be able to coordinate interoperable approaches for open data change, as various institutions and organizations produce and manage geographical data. This thesis aims to develop a data model that can be applied to disaster data produced by different institutions and organizations under different structures and standards according to TUCBS natural risk zones data theme. 3 1.2 Method The aim is to develop a data model suitable for the natural risk zones data theme for the integrated management of disaster data produced by different institutions and organizations. The samples can be used in disaster management-related applications by transforming the data samples from the natural risk regions data theme into the defined data exchange format. It examines and illustrates the necessary transformation methods for converting data of different formats into the specified Geographical Markup Language (GML) format and storing them there. GML data production, use, updating, presentation, and sharing are examined and sampled using open data softwar 4 5 2. GENERAL INFORMATIONS 2.1 Geographical Information Systems GIS (Geographical Information Systems) are computer systems for managing, creating, analyzing, and mapping various types of data. Location data and attribute data which describe location data are shown on a map via GIS. Thanks to this ability, a foundation is provided in science and nearly all industries for analyzing and mapping (Url-2). When considered the first word for Geographical Information System, geographic, refers to the known or calculated location of data from the point of Geographical coordinate; the second-word information refers that GIS data are arranged to profit useful knowledge; and the third word, systems, refer that GIS consists of various related and dependent components that have different functions. Storing the features of the location and the different data that arise due to these features in different map layers and the use of these layers in the decision-making processes has led to the emergence of GIS (Tastan, 2021). The design of GIS includes banding together spatial data into a unified database and coming from different sources and usually using diverse digital data structures. GIS has a series of data layers, and these layers explain spatially changing phenomena in a spatial register, which means overlapping accurately at all locations (Bonham-Carter et al., 1994). Because the GIS is a system that has a big role in mapping Geographical features on the Earth, GIS has a specific role in information systems. This role is becoming more important by developing technology. Dynamic maps using GIS data could become accessible with web technology and be published on web-based GIS (Web GIS). Also, new methods like big data, machine learning, and AI could be implemented into GIS data for developing spatial analysis and making predictions with GIS data. These kinds of developments increase the importance of GIS and create new usage areas for GIS. 2.1.1 GIS components GIS has five components. These are Hardware, Software, Data, and Methods. Hardware consists of all kinds of computer internal and external hardware (Tastan, 6 2021). Software procures tools and functions for analyzing, storing, and displaying. There are both open and closed sources in GIS software. The third component, data, is the most important component. GIS data and related attributes data could be collected in-house or could be bought from a commercial data provider. People are also an important component because people play roles in the decision-making processes for real-life problems. They manage the system and develop plans. Achieving a successful GIS depends on the design of the plan and business rules. The business rules could be unique for each organization's purpose. 2.1.2 Data models for GIS For visualization of Geographical features, the first process is to determine the way of the best representation of Geographical space (Bonham-Carter et al., 1994). Data models are a set of rules that explain relationships between data tables, indicate the ways for reaching records and detect frames for data explanations and data usage (Tastan, 2015; Cabuk et al., 2011). Raster data models and vector data models are two major data models. Raster data models: Raster data (Also known as cell-based data) is generally used for the definition of Geographical presence, which has continuous features (Ates, 2010). Each cell is known as a pixel, and each layer of grid cells records a separate attribute. The size of the cells is constant, and the shape of the cells is generally square. The rows and columns are used for stating the locations of cells (Bonham-Carter et al., 4 1994). The spatial resolution of the raster model is determined by the area covered by each pixel. Square pixels can be measured by measuring one of their sides to determine their resolution. The 10m spatial resolution in a raster model refers to pixels representing 10 m by 10 m in the real world. (Bonham-Carter et al., 1994). Vector data models: There are three types of vector data types which are points, lines, and polygons. These vector data models are stored by coding (x, y) coordinates values. Only one (x, y) coordinate value is stored for point features, while the (x, y) coordinate series value is stored for line features. Polygon features are stored as closed features as initial and final points have the same (x, y) coordinate. Points are zero-dimensional features that generally present district features like buildings, center points, sample points, etc. Lines are one-dimensional features that are a combination of explicit and more than one-point features that present linear features like roads, rivers, streams, etc. 7 Polygons are two-dimensional features that combinations of multiple lines and polygons generally present closed features like city boundaries, lakes, etc. Figure 2. 1 : Vector Data Models. 2.1.3 GIS process There are six main GIS processes in GIS. There are Data Capture, Data Manipulation, Data Management, Querying & Analyze, and Presentation Data. 2.1.3.1 Data capture Manual digitization and scanning are two basic methods of digitization which GIS data are generally obtained from. Digitization of photography, digital datasets and paper maps, GPS, remote sensing, and satellite imagery data are input sources of GIS. 2.1.3.2 Data manipulation Data manipulation is a necessary process for making GIS projects or GIS data suitable for users' systems. Although temporary transformation could be for displaying, permanent transformations are necessary for analysis. 8 2.1.3.3 Data management According to the GIS project size, storage methods may change. Storing as a simple file could be adequate for small GIS Projects. But, when data volume and user number increase, using a database management system (DBMS) is the best way to store, organize and manage data. The relational design of DBMS is the most useful design for GIS because of its flexibility and wide deployment in applications. The flexibility of the software and its wide deployment within and outside GIS make it an ideal solution for a variety of applications. 2.1.3.4 Query & analyze Basic queries such as distances between two locations and analytical questions like traffic control by ring roads could be done when Geographical data is entered into GIS. Also, results could be taken a few times. It is important for managers and analysts to be able to access timely information using GIS, which provides them with both simple point-and-click query capabilities and sophisticated analysis tools. Proximity and Overlay Analyses are the two most important analytic tools of GIS (Url-2). Proximity analysis is used to determine the proximity between features. Buffering method is used for this analysis. Overlay analysis is the combination of different data layers. It could be used for visualization for the simplest purpose. Physical join of one or more data is required for analytical operations. 2.1.3.5 Visualization The aim of using visualization is to increase complexity and highlight the main purpose of information by using the key features. Thanks to visualization, the complex process could be clearer, and deciding could be easier. Maps, 2D-3D models, simulations, graphs, and other cartographic products are visualization tools that are presented in GIS. 2.2 Disaster and Disaster Management 2.2.1 Disaster There are many definitions of disaster in the literature. It is defined as "a natural or human-induced phenomenon affecting humans and other living things that disrupt normal life and social activities, causes physical, social, cultural, and economic losses 9 to society, and cannot be overcome by the affected community" (Gundogdu & Ozcep, 2003). Also, it can be expressed as insufficient resources in the intervention. In this definition, the prerequisite is that the affected community cannot cope independently. It is incorrect to consider every earthquake and fire a disaster. For example, the tsunami claimed to have occurred in the August 17 Earthquake cannot be considered a disaster. However, on December 26, 2004, the 9-magnitude earthquake and the tsunami that occurred off the Indonesian island of Sumatra caused the death of more than 230 thousand people in more than ten countries, 168 thousand of which were in Indonesia, and became one of the biggest disasters in the last century. Again, the tsunami caused by the 8.3-magnitude earthquake on the Indonesian island of Sumatra did not create a disaster effect. When evaluating its dimensions, it is important to consider how the disaster impacts society in its natural cycle. The scientific development in all studies on this subject is in parallel with the disaster culture of society. Societies' view of disasters until recently XIX. It was viewed similarly to diseases at the beginning of the century as "an unforeseen, unwanted, and unavoidable risk of daily living. With increased social development, scientific progress, and the importance given to human life, society's view of disasters has begun to change. It has been understood that disasters can be prevented or overcome with minor damage if necessary, and precautions are taken beforehand. 2.2.1.1 Factor causing disaster Disaster is the result of an event rather than itself (Ergunay, 2002). Considering the consequences of disasters; first, it is seen that they cause loss of life and property. Loss of life is death of people and animals, loss of property is damage to property, buildings, and agricultural areas. While some losses may occur directly with the disaster, others may occur after a certain period. For example, loss of life and property occurs during floods. However, after the flood, the debris, sand, and mud brought by the floods can also cause indirect and long-term damages by rendering agricultural lands unproductive. The reason that the disaster phenomenon increasingly occupies the agenda of the country, and the world is that there was an increase of 35% in the number of disaster 10 events that occurred in the world between 1991 and 1993, announced by the United Nations Humanitarian Relations Department. 2.2.1.2 Disaster types Disaster types can best be described as follows: 2.2.1.2.1 Natural disasters These are disasters that are based on natural events. These are examined in two groups, geological and meteorological: Disasters of geological origin: These are natural disasters that take their source directly from the earth's crust or depths. For example, earthquakes, landslides, erosion, volcanic eruptions (Volcanoes), mud flood, and rockfall. Meteorological origins: They occur because of natural events in the atmosphere. These occur when atmospheric events (temperature, precipitation, pressure, and wind) exceed the limit of what is beneficial to man. The main factors preparing the formation of meteorological disasters originate in the atmosphere, but the characteristics of the place where the disaster occurs are also important. Flood, drought, mass movements, avalanche, storm, hurricane, tornado, blizzard, hail, extreme cold, storm, forest fire, global climate changes, lightning strike, greenhouse effect, frost, fog and excessive rain can be given as examples. 2.2.1.2.2 Unnatural disasters Occurrences are man-made disasters. For example, wars and civil wars, some forest fires, fires in residential areas, hazardous material accidents, nuclear accidents, air pollution, water pollution, soil erosion and epidemics, armed attack, riots, terrorism, and displacement of people and becoming refugees. Other events that cause it include fires, epidemics, diseases caused by water and food, infectious diseases, cholera, malaria, etc. 2.2.1.2.3 Complex disasters They are both man-made and natural disasters. For example, forest fires and fires after earthquakes. Fires fall into all three groups listed above. Some disasters also bring with them disasters called secondary disasters. For example, earthquakes, tsunamis, landslides, epidemics, and fires cause a striking example in this regard. 11 Types of disasters are also considered dangerous and classified according to their process and nature. - Sudden hazards (geological and meteorological hazards): earthquakes, tsunamis, floods, volcanic eruptions, - Slow emerging hazards (environmental hazards): drought, hunger, environmental degradation, desertification, etc., - Industrial/technological hazards: System collapses, accidents, radiation, etc. Types of disasters observed in the world. Geological Disasters: Earthquake, rockfall, volcanic eruptions, mudflows, tsunami Climatic Disasters: Heat waves, cold waves, drought, hail, tornado, lightning, hurricane, typhoons, floods, cyclones, tornados, avalanches, heavy snow, rains, acid rains, fog, icing, weather pollution, forest fires Biological Disasters: Erosion, forest fires, epidemics, insect infestation, Social disasters: Fires, wars, terrorist attacks, migrations, Technological disasters: Mining accidents, biological, nuclear, chemical weapons and accidents, industrial accidents, and transportation accidents (Url-3). If it is accepted that there are approximately 52 types of disasters worldwide, it can be assumed that approximately 21 occurred in Türkiye. It is seen that meteorological disasters form 28 types of thirty-one natural disasters. Natural disaster’s types and order of importance also vary from country to country. For example, natural disasters in the Mediterranean region are drought, floods, forest fires, landslides, hailstorms, avalanches, and frosts. Türkiye's most common meteorological natural disasters are hail, floods, frost, forest fires, drought, heavy rain, strong wind, lightning, avalanche, snow, and storms. According to the World Meteorological Organization (WMO), 700,000 people lost their lives due to meteorological disasters in the 1980’s alone (Url-4). In general, terms, when we look at the rates of disasters in our country, earthquake comes first at 61%, followed by landslides at 15% and floods at 14%. Earthquakes and floods have taken the top two spots in the last ten years based on historical data. 12 According to the Turkish Criminal Code, 1959, 7269/ 1 Disaster Law, the order of importance of disasters in Türkiye is:  earthquake,  fire,  flood,  landslide,  rockfall,  avalanche,  drought. (İsik et al., 2013) The analysis of natural disasters occurring between 1980 and 2017 indicates that an average of six to 25 people per million died in natural disasters during this period. In terms of the number of major earthquakes since 1900, Türkiye ranks fourth. As compared to other types of disaster, earthquakes cause the greatest number of deaths and property damage. A significant percentage (60%) of disaster-related deaths are caused by earthquakes. Based on statistical evaluations of the earthquakes that have occurred in Türkiye to date, it appears that a major earthquake with extensive damage occurs once every five years, on average. The number of people who die and are injured each year is reported to be approximately 1,000. Additionally, earthquakes cause more than 7,000 buildings to be destroyed or severely damaged each year (Url- 5). All these data confront us with the reality of developing mitigation strategies before the disaster and producing a radical policy within a sustainable development framework. 2.2.2 Disaster management There is a need for structuring management organizations in accordance with the environmental characteristics of disaster events, which require societies to be prepared in an organized manner. Every human community engages in management activities to achieve a common goal (İsik et al., 2013; Simsek, 1996). 13 "Disaster Management" emerged in response to this need and aims to coordinate and manage the activities that need to be carried out during disaster phases (Sarp, 1999). This concept envisages not ignoring or eliminating disasters but managing them with the acceptance of their existence, reducing and controlling their harmful effects. Disaster management, in a broader sense, is a broad concept that requires planning, directing, and coordination of the works to be done in the prevention of disasters or reduction of damages, mitigation, preparation, rescue and first aid, improvement, and reconstruction of a disaster event. In order for this to be feasible, all institutions and organizations must use their resources for this common purpose. In summary, it is an effort to overcome extraordinary situations that lead to disasters. As a brief definition, disaster management includes coordinating and managing the activities that need to be carried out during the disaster phase. Furthermore, it entails the development and implementation of long-term and comprehensive policies as well as the development and implementation of preparedness strategies in disaster- hazardous regions in the pre-disaster period and the conduct of risk reduction studies to prevent or reduce disaster impacts. Management of disasters involves rescue efforts after an earthquake, hurricane, or another natural disaster; in the longer term, it involves managing the reorganization of social systems and individual lives resulting from that disaster. In disaster-prone areas, disaster management covers the development and implementation of preparedness strategies against a possible disaster, along with the development of long-term, comprehensive policies concerning risk reduction studies that will be conducted for the prevention or reduction of disaster effects, as well as the management of implementation studies (Schramm & Newman, 1997). Disaster management is defined as, "A way of preventing disasters and reducing damages. "Being prepared for disasters, providing fast and effective rescue, first aid, temporary shelter, and reconstruction during disasters, society's resources (manpower, material, equipment, and money) need to be guided and used rationally before and after a disaster. According to a UNDP/UNDRO Disaster Management Handbook published in 1991, disaster management encompasses:  Planning and executing measures to reduce the likelihood of disasters by reducing the negative effects of possible disasters and considering the economic aspect. 14  Making warning-preparation arrangements against the immediate threat of disaster, arranging effective emergency measures in case of alarm or warning periods and dire consequences of disaster impact.  Determine the situation of the region and the people living there in the event of collapse, floods, famine, and "slow progress" disasters, and promptly implement solutions and measures.  Implementation of emergency relief efforts for (immediately) lifesaving immediately after the disaster,  Accelerating rehabilitation measures that will accelerate recovery and promote continuous post-disaster development. In line with the definitions above, the first point to be noted regarding "disaster management" is that disaster management, which has a vast scope, does not concern only one sector or administrative unit. A holistic approach to disasters and disaster management should be exhibited on a sectoral and organizational basis (Ergunay 2002, İsik et al., 2013). Disaster management also requires qualified personnel with expertise in a variety of disciplines. Regarding disaster mitigation, seismology, hydrology, and meteorology come together with wind and earthquake engineering. Furthermore, health experts and policy development managers play a crucial role in developing strategies to protect society from the socioeconomic and medical effects of disasters. In 1990, disaster management practices should consider the following five points. Specifically, the following points are in question:  Management of disasters is generally not limited to a particular region where disasters occur.  Because most disasters today are caused by natural causes, disaster management should be handled together with environmental problems. These problems are attracting global attention now.  Before developing disaster mitigation strategies at the national, regional, and local levels, it is important to determine which areas will be affected by which disasters, and why.  The state should apply economic efficiency, economic incentives, and free market forces for the health, protection, and welfare of society. 15  Development policies and strategies that contribute to an increase in disaster damage should be changed (Bender, 1992). As part of the "International 10 Years of Reducing the Damages of Natural Disasters", a United Nations organization established in the 1990s to work on natural disaster prevention, the Scientific and Technical Committee promotes disaster prevention, disaster preparedness, mitigation of disaster damages, and a culture of global prevention. Effective disaster management is essential for the realization of the 2000 strategy, which can be summarized as "development and development". Managing disasters is primarily concerned with the rescue of people, the restoration of normal living conditions, and the salvaging of damaged property. Achieving this goal requires knowledge, experience, planning, and coordination. Comprehensive disaster management aims to achieve the following objectives: 1. By taking the necessary technical, administrative, and legal measures before the event, society will be able to deal with the disaster with only minor damage and losses. 2. In cases where measures cannot be taken, the most appropriate intervention studies should be carried out. 3. Incorporating mitigation efforts into all stages of development. 4. Assuring that every segment of society has access to the necessary information and education. The design of processes for the most efficient use of resources can be highly beneficial to the mitigation and preparedness for disasters. As a result of considering the ability to cope with disasters or minimize damage, it is concluded that disaster resources are insufficient. Risk analysis and resource development studies can help reduce damages before a disaster occurs. Management of resources by considering risk is the essence of Disaster Management. Realizing this situation is possible with an organization that can coordinate all institutions and organizations that have completed their institutional restructuring. To accomplish this, an event command center is established within an information system that is capable of utilizing resources efficiently. This organization is known as Disaster Management. It is much more devastating when a disaster that occurred previously occurs today with the same severity. This can be attributed to three main factors: the expansion of the area covered by settlements that are at risk of natural 16 disasters, the increase in population density in these settlements, and the difficulty of controlling them. When disaster management is examined in different countries, it is found that it is structured according to the country's social, geographical, economic, and political conditions. Modern disaster management prioritizes a high level of mitigation and prevention. All public institutions and organizations participate actively in the development of this structure. Effective disaster management requires, analizing disaster risks, taking measures to minimize damage, determining the procedures to follow during disasters, and implementing these measures promptly. Keeping this objective in mind should guide the management of all institutions and resources of society. 2.2.2.1 Phases of disaster management and the disaster cycle Disaster management system: It consists of two separate management systems that are complementary to one another. a) Loss Mitigation (Risk) Management, b) Emergency (Crisis) Management. Regardless of their origins and pace of development, all disaster-related activities are divided into the following four main stages: a. Mitigation, b. Preparedness, c. Response to the incident. d. Remediation. As part of the Disaster Management process, a cycle begins with mitigation and preparedness and continues with response, recovery, and reconstruction following a disaster. This cycle should include hazard identification, disaster prevention, mitigation, reinforcement, rehabilitation preparation, education, early warning, support, and emergency planning. Figure 2.2 illustrates the disaster cycle. 17 Figure 2. 2 : Disaster Management Cycle. The first two stages cover the activities before the disaster, and the other two include the activities during and after the disaster. The activities that need to be done at these stages are not independent of each other, they are intertwined and must follow each other, and the effectiveness of the work done in the previous stage is the activities that significantly affect the success and efficiency of the work in the next stage and should show continuity. The concepts to be understood before the disaster can be given as follows: Hazard: Everything that has the potential to cause loss of life and property, as well as to damage the socioeconomic order and activities, Risk: The estimated adverse effect of a hazard on residents, properties, activities, unique facilities, or structures of the area. Risk Management = mitigation + preparedness Risk = Risk Estimation x Sensitivity Crisis Management (Fix) = Hazard, Risk Vulnerability: This concept can be defined as the relative lack of the power of an individual or society to predict the effects of a disaster, fight against it, and even resist them. The leading factors that increase people's vulnerability in case of disasters are rapid urbanization, population growth, lack of building control, and lack of disaster information and awareness (Koç & Thieken, 2017). Briefly, in societies that cannot predict and take precautions about the hazards and effects of disasters in natural events, natural events appear as a disaster risk that can lead to loss of life and property (Rattien, 1990). 18 2.3 GIS and Disaster Management 2.3.1 Development of GIS Technology contributes to the development of Geographical Information Systems (GIS) on the one hand and their widespread application in a variety of disciplines on the other. In general, GIS can be defined in two ways: in terms of technology, GIS is a tool that collects, stores, processes, transforms, and displays real-world spatial data. From a theoretical and institutional perspective, GIS is a decision-support system that interacts with spatial data. Combined with both definitions, GIS can be viewed as a digital information system that provides decision support. In essence, it collects, stores, processes, and displays spatial data in accordance with the needs of the institution with which it is affiliated. Each group constitutes a GIS organization based on its functions. Screen maps or printed (analog) maps are the main output formats of GIS or digital image processing systems. Geographical Information Systems differ from other information systems in terms of the types of data they contain and how these data are characterized. This type of data has the characteristic of allowing the location of objects or events (phenomena) on earth to be determined. The purpose of a map is to visualize the location of objects or events in relation to one another (Ulugtekin & Dogru). To resolve location-related problems, maps are used as visual communication tools. Many GIS users have questions regarding the environment or the nature of a particular object. Answering these questions poses the question of what type and scale of map to use. In general, GIS maps can be categorized under the following headings: - Cadastral maps - Service maps (gas, water, wastewater, electricity, telephone, cable broadcast, etc.) - Socio-economic maps (maps derived from statistics on population, infrastructure, settlement, job distribution, education, agriculture, etc.) - Environmental maps (vegetation, soil, hydrology, geology, forest, etc.) 19 - Other maps (maps associated with the use or especially the misuse of resources such as water pollution, air, and soil pollution) Cadastral and service maps are generally large-scale. Small-scale maps are generally used in geospatial analysis. When working with spatial data in a GIS environment, "What?, Where?, When?" Three basic types of inquiries are encountered, such as: - The spatial comparison is the comparison of features across different regions in the same spatial scale. - Thematic comparison refers to mapping issues for the same region at the same scale and comparing the spatial distribution of similar or different issues. - In temporal comparison studies, the same subject changes in the same scale and region over time (Ulugtekin & Dogru). Prior to the advent of GIS, paper maps and statistics were the most effective tools for researchers working with spatial data. For the analysis and use of these paper maps, analytical and map-using techniques have been developed. Several of these techniques are also included in GIS packages. Researchers use compelling databases, spreadsheet software, and graphical tools in their research today. This convenience allows the user to access the map data more easily and reduces the processing load. GIS is used to support decision-making, and decisions are related to geographical objects. It is the goal of GIS to ensure that employees are capable of analyzing and interpreting data correctly. The majority of GIS practitioners are evasive at this point. Among the goals of GIS is to assist users in making accurate and timely decisions. For accurate decision-making, data quality becomes increasingly imperative. In terms of integrating data sets, GIS can provide very successful results. Data acquisition dates, spatial resolution degrees, and differences between concepts become apparent to GIS users. 2.3.2 GIS and disaster management People have migrated significantly from rural areas to metropolitan cities due to rapid population growth and economic problems experienced throughout the world. As a result of unplanned and irregular urbanization along with these migrations, regions that are unprepared for disasters may suffer severe losses in terms of life and property. 20 As stated in the book Disaster Management, Expecting the Unexpected, Managing the Worst, "it is impossible to reduce environmental problems and achieve sustainable development without considering disasters. Sustainable development requires reducing disaster risks. Investments that are not made in disaster management programs result in post-disaster losses. As a result, identifying, evaluating, and managing risks in addition to conducting hazard and damage analyses are integral parts of sustainable development." It is critical to be prepared for disasters as a foundation for sustainable development (Tasdemir, 2020). It is significant to understand that disaster management involves multidimensional research and evaluation of a wide range of data simultaneously. In scientific research on disasters and in disaster management planning, it is necessary to analyze a wide variety of data simultaneously, taking into account the relationships between them. The use of Geographical Information Systems has become a very important tool in disaster management, as they address all these needs and allow multi-dimensional spatial analyses of data of all kinds. Geographical information systems refer to the methods of transferring all kinds of data relating to the earth to a computer environment. It is possible to store, classify, compare, analyze, update, and visualize these data via maps, graphics, and tables using these systems. In the first half of the 19th century, GIS was first used for the analysis of post-disaster damage. It was not until the beginning of the 20th century that GIS was conceptually defined. The Canadian GIS project was developed by Roger Tomlinson in 1963. The purpose of this project was to calculate the characteristics of the national lands of Canada. By combining spatial and non-spatial data and ensuring that spatial and non-spatial data are evaluated together, Geographical Information Systems have been used for epidemic mapping since 1832, conceptualized in 1963, and translated into a project affecting countries across the globe to optimize land use. Therefore, using GIS in disasters, as in other areas, would ensure that the right decisions are made and that one could escape the disaster with the least damage (Tasdemir, 2020). There is no doubt that preparing for and responding to disasters is as significant as responding during and after them. Both stages are integral to the overall process. GIS 21 is one of the most effective tools for determining what needs to be done and how it needs to be done. By using GIS, we are able to monitor disasters, develop disaster risk maps, develop early warning systems, prepare various disaster scenarios, develop emergency support plans, develop alternative evacuation and transportation plans in the event of a potential disaster, plan open spaces, protect recreational areas and plan for public safety. 2.4 GIS Standards 2.4.1 INSPIRE A directive called INSPIRE (Infrastructure for Spatial Information in the European Community), which was approved and published by the European Union Parliament on July 23, 2004, established a legal framework for GIS activities within the European Union. All Union member states are obligated to comply with the technical and administrative requirements of the INSPIRE DIRECTIVE (Directive of the European Parliament and the Council - INSPIRE). It is the objective of the INSPIRE project to enable European users to access CURRENT geographical information in REAL TIME. There are four main steps to accomplish this objective. Documenting the geographical data sets in European Union countries and developing the tools required to access them are the first steps. The second stage involves harmonizing data sets accessed from different sources into a standard system and making them available. During the third stage, existing data sets are integrated by developing standard geographical data models for geographical objects (for example, transportation, forests, etc.). The fourth and final stage is to provide services that allow the integration of geographical data sets on a national and local level, with various levels (scales) and sources, into a continuous geographical database based on common standards and protocols (Url-6). 2.4.2 Turkish National Geographical Information System (TUCBS) It is a geographical information system that can be integrated into the Turkish National Geographical Information System. TUCBS is local, regional, and national geographical information systems that can share data over computer networks and be 22 accessed by everyone, including ordinary citizens. TUCBS is also defined as a network of data and service providers enabling the joint use of geographical data and services. The term "service" refers to the collection, storage, processing, analysis, presentation, and sharing of geographical data. With the data and services provided by TUCBS, users will be able to model and implement their applications. TUCBS is open to all relevant public and private sector organizations, local governments, universities, and other organizations at the country level. 2.4.3 OGC (Open Geospatial Consortium) OGC carries out studies parallel with the ISO/TC211 committee and offers more relevant solutions with the prepared standards. OGC, recognized as the GIS industry association, consists of member organizations and companies working to ensure and improve the interoperability of Geographical information technologies. OGC's vision is to create a network, application, or platform that can benefit anyone who uses or needs Geographical information. Its mission is to make the relevant interface and technical standards available to all users. OGC continues its multi-faceted efforts to create web services. As a result of these studies, standards based on web service logic have been prepared. In order (OGC, 2003, 2006). - Web Map Service (WMS): It transmits data with coordinate information to the client as images or maps. It is an application standard published as ISO 19128 standard. - Web Feature Service (WFS): It is a service that allows sending vector data kept in different formats on servers to the client in GML format. Vector includes data access, new data creation, query, straightforward analysis, data deletion, and data update features. - Web Coverage Service (WCS): Provides raster data with its features and allows complex queries corresponding to this data. It differs from WFS and WMS in this approach. 23 - Catalog for the Web (CS/W): Searching, finding, accessing, etc., Geographical data from Internet-based metadata catalogs. Transactions can be performed with catalog services. - Coordinate Transformation Service (CRS): Provides a standard way to define and transform coordinate systems. 2.5 Databases 2.5.1 Database model The database is the storage of related data allowing multi-purpose use and without duplication. A database management system interacts with end users, applications, and databases for analyzing and capturing data and is defined as software (Url-7). The database model includes the rules and tools for database design and the production of result enforcement standards. The complicated problems are solved by using database models. Real-world problems are transformed into more fundamental and manageable problems. As geodatabase models have evolved, this concept has been defined as "entity" in a relational database and "object" in object-oriented database models (Aydinoglu, 2009). Database Modeling provides methods and tools for a high-level description of the real world. Database designer, using the required dictionary and schema rules to generate the database model. In this sense, the high-level definition provides an approach everyone can perceive in the real world. An event refers to the use of an object in the database at a specified time. Database models and schemas are static and time-independent because they express objects by structure and repetition of use. The Conceptual Database Model is a function that abstracts real-world entities' properties and characteristics depending on the database's purpose. The Conceptual Scheme describes the properties of the database independent of computer software and hardware requirements. Information is stored in the database, and its attribute and relations can be determined with Entity Relationships and Class diagrams. The Logical Database Model defines the details defined in the conceptual database model with schemas in data structures according to the application. The relational 24 database schema of the conceptual database design produced with UML diagrams is defined in Figure 2.3. Figure 2. 3 : UML and ER diagrams (Aydinoglu, 2009). The physical Database Model is a more complex and technical process as it requires the suitability of the database to the software and hardware in which it is used. With the detail catalogs produced in this context, the name, geometry, attributes, type, relations, etc. of the detailed class. Information can be identified. 2.5.2 Geographical databases A geodatabase or geographical database is a relational database for storing Geographical data. Geographical Databases are the foundation of GIS and are generally classified according to the database model. Geometry and attribute data related to geometry are stored in geodatabases. The concept of geometry has been modified with the publication of the OGC Simple Feature Specification for SQL (Aydinoglu, 2009). OGC has proposed the "Geometry Object 40 Model" in Figure 2.4, which allows for details to be presented in databases. In this model, geometry types are defined in a specific hierarchy, and details are presented as a "feature" with at least one attribute in a geometry type. The basic geometry class consists of 4 subclasses: Point, Line (Curve), Area (Surface), and Geometry Collection (Aydinoglu, 2009). Geographical features have a coordinate system, geometries have the same attributes as layer or feature classes and are stored in the same tables. ER DIAGRAM UML DIAGRAM 25 Figure 2. 4 : OGC geometry object model (OGC, 1999; Aydinoglu, 2009). 2.6 Development of TUCBS Due to the widespread use of computers and information technologies, the volume of digital data produced by different institutions, organizations, and companies has increased over time. There are several reasons for this development, including:  Establishing a standard format for data produced by different institutions on similar topics.  Identify the principles that will ensure the sharing and use of data produced by different organizations by making the necessary legal and organizational arrangements. These principles will be under the authority and responsibility of different organizations.  In the case of data produced by different institutions or obtained on the same subject, determine the responsibility areas of each institution.  To prevent the waste of time, personnel, and resources caused by the reproduction of data obtained, etc., coordination and other mechanisms should be developed. Geographical information systems play an integral role in providing the ability to combine or use the data produced by multiple organizations. Several projects have been conducted to determine the standards for the production and sharing of digital geographical information by providing a common standard. This 26 has led to interinstitutional coordination of geographical information produced within the authority and responsibilities of public institutions and organizations by providing a common standard. Study on the establishment of Geographical Information Systems Standards in which other institutions participated, coordinated by TÜBİTAK and HGK. Under the coordination of the Prime Minister and the HGK, these studies can be categorized as Inter-Institutional Coordination. At the Coordination of GIS Establishment Studies Symposium and Panel held on February 4, 1999, the "Turkish National Geographical Information System (TUCBS) Policy and Strategy Principles Draft" document was prepared. This draft describes the principles for the production, revision, and exchange of geographical information by public institutions and organizations according to areas of responsibility, according to authorities, and responsibilities to be determined by cooperation between institutions. TUCBS has been accelerated through the General Directorate of GIS, which was established in 2011 under the Ministry of Environment and Urbanization. With the concept of Geographical/Spatial Data Infrastructure (SDI) which is expressed around the world, TUCBS data standards are created, approaches for interoperability of geographical data and systems from local to national level on a service-based basis, and TUCBS portal are developed. Through the Conceptual Data Model Components, rules are determined to create data standards that can be used from national to local levels and are interoperable. Establishing the conceptual data model components of data themes based on the principles of the ISO/TC211 Geographical Information Technical Committee, the Open Geographical Information Consortium, and other internationally accepted initiatives such as INSPIRE. TUCBS is a common data model that contains standard data sets that different sectors are required to share. It is necessary for TUCBS geographical data models to be compatible for this purpose. It is therefore essential that interoperability be ensured with applications in various sectors, such as the TUCBS primary data standards and the TRKBIS standard (Yomralıoğlu & Aydınoğlu, 2014). 27 Figure 2. 5 : TUCBS standard hierarchy (CBSGM, 2012a). Within the scope of the project for the development of TRKBIS standards, analyses consisting of 8 work packages were conducted in 2012. The data requirement defined in legislation and works related to the Legislation Analysis (IP.1) has been determined. In the selected sample municipalities, the current situation analysis was made with Institutional Analysis (IP.2), and the process analysis, data requirement analysis, and current data analysis of the identified works related to urban information systems were made with Data Requirements Analysis (IP.3). With the Analysis of International Standards (IP.4), approaches that can be taken as examples from the world have been determined. Based on all these analysis results, the TUCBS-compliant TRKBISS Conceptual Model Components (IP.5), Data Standards Determination (IP.6), and Data Exchange Format Development (IP.7) work packages were completed. In addition, a Draft of Administrative and Financial Legislation (IP.8) has been prepared (CBSGM, 2014). DATA EXCHANGE International Standard National Standard Sector Standard Institutional Standard 28 Figure 2. 6 : TRKBIS Project work packages. In 2014, draft data and schema documents and 1.1 version documents of TUCBS were shared openly with users on the General Directorate of GIS website. The TUCBS Portal was opened to users in 2020 under the name Atlas. Atlas Portal is a modular portal designed to provide users with the data they produce or update in public institutions and organizations that produce geographical data. The data is created according to the Open GIS Consortium (OGC) standards, which set GIS standards worldwide (CBS General Directorate, 2020). In 2019, Presidential Decree No. 49 on Geographical Information Systems was published in the T.C. Resmî Gazete. No. 30941. By establishing the Turkish Geographical Information System Board, the Turkish Geographical Information System Executive Board, and the Turkish Geographical Information System Working Committee, it will ensure coordination of public institutions and organizations as well as provide principles and standards for the production, updating, management, access, security, sharing, distribution, and use of geographical data themes. The Turkish GIS Board of the General Directorate of GIS produced the National Geographical Information Strategy and Action Plan in June 2020. In addition to the action plan, a data responsibility matrix has been developed. Six objectives, 27 targets, and 46 actions are defined in the Action Plan. Analysis of International Standards (IP4) Developmen t of KBS Data Exchange Format (IP7) Making Administrative and Financial Modelling and Preparing Draft Legislation (IP8) Legislative Analysis (IP1) Data Requirements Analysis (IP3) Data Requirements Analysis Current Data Analysis KBS Application Examples Main Standards Conceptual Data Model Design (IP5) Institutional Analysis (IP2) Business Process Analysis Legislative Requirement Setting of Spatial Data Standarts (IP6) B u si n e ss D e sc ri p ti o n 29 In summary, it involves creating a monitoring and reporting system suitable for decision support systems that is directly linked to processes. In addition, it involves considering the needs of producers and users (T.C. Resmî Gazete, 2020). 2.7 TUCBS Geodata Themes The Definition Documents and Standards for Geographical Data Themes training document outlines how to create a roadmap that will enable data producers, public institutions, and organizations to share geographical data by standards over the National Geographical Information Platform. The general headings in this document are listed below: - Data Description Documents - Data Content and Structure in Data Description Documents - Reference Systems, Units of Measure, and Grids - ISO 19157 Data Quality Components - ISO 19115 Metadata Standard - Examples of Data Reconciliation Using Data Definition Documents - Conclusion and Evaluation In accordance with the scope of Presidential Decree No. 49 on Geographical Information Systems, national and international standards are used to determine and update geographical data themes. As part of the process of preparing Data Identification Documents, the General Directorate of Geographical Information Systems prepared the Guidelines for Interoperability Procedures and Principles, the Technical Interoperability Procedures and Principles, the General Conceptual Model, and the General Concepts Glossary documents, which served as the basis for the creation of the Data Identification Documents. Relevant documents are published by the General Directorate of Geographical Information Systems at Url-8. Geographical data, the most essential and fundamental component of the Turkish National Geographical Information System (TUCBS), refers to all kinds of data containing location information. Geographical data consists of geometry information, 30 location information expressed in coordinates, and non-spatial attribute information. A hierarchical structure for grouping geographical data is shown in Figure 2.7. Figure 2. 7 : Hierarchical structure for modeling Geographical data in Geographical data themes. Within the scope of data themes, the structure of the geographical data and how it will be presented are explained together with the schema rules. The data to be shared is expected to comply with the theme standards and schema rules. Table 2.1 shows Geographical Data Themes. Sub-theme groups (category information) belonging to the geographical data theme are part of the high-level classification system to support the grouping and subject- based search of existing spatial data sources. Table 2.2 shows the classification system used in the metadata generation phase. After selecting a TUCBS theme group of Geographical data from this table, it can be used when creating metadata by determining its sub-theme (category). The category information within each theme group is also listed in the table in question. 31 Table 2. 1 : Geographical Data Themes. NO THEME 1 Coordinate Reference Systems and Geographical Grid Systems 2 Administrative Units 3 Geographical Names 4 Cadaster 5 Buildings 6 Addresses 7 Elevation 8 Orthoimagery 9 Transport Networks 10 Hydrography 11 Geology 12 Land Cover 13 Land Use 14 Soil 15 Protected Sites 16 Natural Risk Zones 17 Infrastructure 18 Energy Resources 19 Mines 20 Human Health and Safety 21 Population Distribution - Demography 22 Environmental Monitoring Facilities 23 Industrial Facilities 24 Agricultural Facilities 25 Public Administration Regions 26 Species Distribution 27 Habitats 28 Biogeography 29 Sea and Salty Water Regions 30 Atmosphere Data 31 Meteorological Data 32 Statistical Reporting Zones 32 Different institutions/organizations in terms of data theme, scope, and content. It was decided to divide them into sub-theme groups if they are of interest to you, for example, Transport Networks Theme - Road Network, Transport Networks Theme - Railway Network. Each data theme was studied by the Theme Working Committees based on sub-theme groups. There are 52 sub-theme groups related to 32 geographical data themes determined within the scope of TUCBS. Table 2. 2 : Sub-theme groups (category information). NO THEME SUB THEME (CATEGORY) 1 Coordinate Reference Systems and Geographical Grid Systems Coordinate Reference Systems 2 Administrative Units Administrative Units 3 Geographical Names Geographical Names 4 Cadaster Cadaster 5 Buildings Buildings 6 Addresses Addresses 7 Elevation Elevation 8 Orthoimagery Orthoimagery_5000_Under Orthoimagery_5000_Above 9 Transport Networks Road Transport Network (Intercity) Road Transport Network (Local) Railway Transport Network Air Transport Network Sea and Water Transport Network Inner City Rail Systems and Cable Transport Network 10 Hydrography Hydrography 11 Geology Geology Hydrogeology Geophysics 12 Land Cover Land Cover 13 Land Use Existing Land Use Planned Land Use 14 Soil Soil 15 Protected Sites Protected Sites 16 Natural Risk Zones Natural Risk Zones 33 Table 2. 2 (continued): Sub-theme groups (category information). NO THEME SUB THEME (CATEGORY) 17 Infrastructure Electric Oil/Gas/Chemical Sewer Water Electronic Communication Thermal Environmental Management Facilities Main Administrative and Social Services 18 Energy Resources Energy Resources Energy Statistics 19 Mines Mines 20 Human Health and Safety Safety Human Health Environmental Quality 21 Population Distribution - Demography Population Distribution - Demography 22 Environmental Monitoring Facilities Environmental Monitoring Facilities 23 Industrial Facilities Industrial Facilities 24 Agricultural Facilities Agricultural Facilities 25 Public Administration Regions Public Administration Regions 26 Species Distribution Species Distribution 27 Habitats Habitats 28 Biogeography Biogeography 29 Sea and Salty Water Regions Sea and Salty Water Regions 30 Atmosphere Data Atmosphere Data 31 Meteorological Data Meteorological Data 32 Statistical Reporting Zones Statistical Reporting Zones 2.7.1 TUCBS Natural risk zones theme It covers the elements needed to define "TUCBS Natural Risk Areas." It provides modeling of hazard, vulnerability, exposure, risk, and observed event concepts. In the data definition guides, models are presented in which the concepts are abstract and can be represented both as vectors (and therefore based on the TS EN ISO 19107 standard) and coverage (and therefore based on the TS EN ISO 19123 standard). 34 There are four Geographical objects modeled as both vectors and coverage. These;  Hazard Area (TehlikeAlani)  Exposed Element (TehlikeAltindakiVarlik)  Risk Zone (RiskBolgesi)  Observed Event (GozlenenOlay) The Natural Risk Zones implementation schemes are not entirely independent but have interdependencies with other TUCBS implementation schemes. Figure 2. 8 : UML Scheme of Natural Risk Zones. 2.7.1.1 “TehlikeAlani” Hazard Area The following Geographical feature types are detailed: “SoyutTehlikeAlani” (AbstractHazardArea) 35 “TehlikeAlani” (HazardArea) “TehlikeAlaniCoverage” (HazardAreaCoverage) Standart features of “SoyutTehlikeAlani” (AbstractHazardArea):  NesneTanimlayici  Determination Method: There are several ways to plot the area of a hazard, these are modelled by using “BelirlemeYontemDegeri” (Determine Methods Value) This data type has two possible values has: - “modelleme” (modelling) - “yorumlama” (interpretation)  Hazard Type: this feature is modelled with the “DogalTehlikeSiniflandirmasi” (Natural Hazard Classification) data type. The data type “DogalTehlikeSiniflandirmasi” (NaturalHazardClassification) contains the code list “DogalTehlikeKategorisiDegeri” (NaturalHazardCategoryValue). The representation of a “TehlikeAlani” must have geometry modeled as GM_Surface. Therefore, all hazard areas are modeled as polygons. Features specific to “TehlikeAlani”: Likelihood of Occurrence: LikelihoodOfOccurrence is a general concept of the probability of an event to occur. This is modeled with the Likelihood of Occurrence data type. This data type has 3 attributes. “degerlendirmeYontemi” (assessmentMethod) means the method used to express the probability of the hazard event, “nitelOlasilik” (qualitativeLikelihood) defines the evaluation of the probability of occurrence of a hazard, “nicelOlasilik” (quantitativeLikelihood) refers to the probability of occurrence or the recurrence interval. Size: A size can be expressed qualitatively or quantitatively. Violence: A violence can be expressed qualitatively or quantitatively. It is possible to use an observed event as an input for hazard area modelling. Therefore, a hazard area may have an observed event as a source. 2.7.1.2 “TehlikeAltindakiVarlik” (ExposedElement) The following Geographical feature types are detailed: 36 “SoyutTehlikeAltindakiVarliklar” (AbstractExposedElement) “TehlikeAltindakiVarlik” (ExposedElement) “TehlikeAltindakiVarlikCoverage” (AbstractExposedElementCoverage) Standard features of “SoyutTehlikeAltindakiVarliklar” (AbstractExposedElement): It refers to the Geographical representation of people, property, systems, or other elements located in hazard areas and, therefore, subject to potential harm. The assessment of vulnerability can be calculated on these geographical objects. Features specific to “TehlikeAlani”: The geometric representation of the exposed element is modeled as GM_Object and allows basically any geometrical construction. Also, this vector geo object contains the same named attribute using the data type "zararGorebilirlikSeviyesi" (assessmentOfVulnerability). This data type has 4 attributes. “ZararGorebilirlikKaynagi” (sourceOfVulnerability) means the interpretation of the vulnerability of the exposed element using the “DogalTehlikSiniflandirmasi” (NaturalHazardClassification) data type. The “ZararGorebilirlikSeviyesi” (levelOfVulnerability) is the result of the assessment of vulnerability. This property is modeled with “SeviyeveyaSiddet” (Level or Intensity) data type. “VarliginTipi” (TypeofElement) is defined to facilitate data interoperability. 2.7.2 “RiskBolgesi” (Risk Zone) The following Geographical feature types are detailed: “SoyutRiskBolgesi” (AbstractRiskZone) “RiskBolgesi” (RiskZone) “RiskBolgesiCoverage” (RiskZoneCoverage) Common features of “SoyutRiskBolgesi” (AbstractRiskZone): A risk zone refers to the geographical extent of the combination of the consequences of an event (hazard) and the associated probability. 37 riskSeviyesi (RiskLevel): riskSeviyesi refers to the assessment of the combination of the consequences of a (hazard) event and the probability of that event occurring. Features specific to “RiskBolgesi”: Vector representation of a risky region is modeled as GM_Surface. Therefore, all risk zones are modeled as polygons. Features specific to “RiskBolgesiCoverage”: Values that vary by location are the risk level. Since the risk level is modeled by the LevelOrSeverity data type, the limitation on the coverage span is for the LevelOrSeverity datatype. Figure 2. 9 : UML Class Diagram: DogalRiskBolgeleri code lists. 2.7.3 “GozlenenOlay” (ObservedEvent) The following Geographical feature types are detailed: “SoyutGozlenenOlay” (AbstractObservedEvent) “GozlenenOlay” (ObservedEvent) 38 “GozlenenOlayCoverage” (ObservedEventCoverage) Common features of “SoyutGozlenenOlay” (AbstractObservedEvent): An observed event refers to the geographical representation of a natural phenomenon that has occurred or is currently occurring and is related to the study of observed natural hazards. Features specific to “GozlenenOlay” (ObservedEvent): The vector representation is modeled as “GM_Object”. This basically covers all geometric primitive types. Features specific to “GozlenenOlayCoverage” (ObservedEventCoverage): Values that vary by location, assess the level or severity of vulnerability. 2.8 Unified Modelling Language/UML UML is a unified modeling language produced by OMG (Object Management Group) for designing and developing standards for object-oriented systems and programs. UML is used in the creation of conceptual schemas for Geographical data management. UML is the basis of the object-oriented-relational modeling method in determining the conceptual model of the modeling field, creating the logical model, and converting it to the physical structure. Application Schema: INSPIRE, ISO 19109, and TUCBS Conceptual Model were used to create the application schema. It integrates the features of each data theme. FeatureType: ISO 19136 and TUCBS geometry standards are considered. A feature class that does not define spatial objects. DataType: It is used to express non-object descriptive, structured data classes within the scope of the ISO 19103 standard. Attribute Value (Enumeration): While defining the attribute value, the ISO 19136 standard is based. A list of values that limits the values that properties and attributes can take. Code List: Within the scope of the ISO 19136 standard, the value list lists the values that properties and attributes can take and defines the code value. 39 Classes: It refers to a set of objects that contain the same function, method, relationship, attribute, behavior, and constraints. A class is a concept intended to be modeled as platform-independent or platform-specific. Every UML class has a name. In addition, it has attributes and relationships, and its functions and restrictions can be defined according to needs (CBSGM, 2012d). UML has two different class types, stereotypes <> and <>. <> defines an object's properties and attributes do not include. <> is a stereotyped class that contains functions/functions, attributes, and relationships that can be applied to objects. Attributes are used to describe the properties of objects in the data model. Each attribute must have a type and be defined. It can have a certain repeatability value. If the repetition value is not defined, this value is accepted as 1. Attribute values and code lists refer to sets of values, or values attributes can take. The code list can be coded according to ISO 3166-1 standard. The selected representation of the code list is value/code. Relationship types between objects in UML rules are defined within the ISO/TS 19103:2005 standard. 2.8.1 UML Relation Types 2.8.1.1 Association Association expresses a weak semantic relationship between two classes. If two classes in a model need to relate to each other, there must be a connection between them. The Association defines the connection. A straight line between two objects expresses Association. Figure 2.10 shows the association relationship between SoyutTehlikeAlani and SoyutGozlenenOlay feature types. The example indicates that a SoyutTehlikeAlani object could associate with no or more SoyutGozlenenOlay objects. 40 Figure 2. 10 : UML Relation Types - Association. Figure 2. 11 : UML multiplicity indicators (Ambler, 2002). 2.8.1.2 Inheritance Inheritance (Generalization) combines similar object classes into a single and general class. A child feature type is a subclass with all the superclass properties and derives from it. The inheritance relationship is indicated by the arrow sign between the two objects. 41 Figure 2. 12 : UML Relation Types - Inheritance (Generalization). As seen in Figure 2.12, there is an inheritance relationship between the SoyutTehlikeAlani and TehlikeAlani feature types. TehlikeAlani is a subclass of SoyutTehlikeAlani. SoyutTehlikeAlani has all the attributes of the SoyutTehlikeAlani parent feature type and its attributes. 2.8.1.3 Aggregation Aggregation is used to divide complex relationships into simple parts. A class in the aggregation relationship could be an integration of simple subparts. The child object could exist independently of the parent object (UML Association vs. aggregation vs. composition). Figure 2. 13 : UML Relation Types – Aggregation (Url-9). 42 2.8.1.4 Composition Composition implies a relationship that is a part of the parent class of one or more feature classes. The child object could not exist independently of the parent object. Figure 2. 14 : UML Relation Types – Composition (Url-9). Figure 2. 15 : UML Relation Types – Association, Aggregation, and Composition (Url-9). 2.8.2 Data modelling with UML Object-oriented geographical database modeling provides a complex application that the relational model cannot resolve. This is used for expressing objects with similar properties in the real world in a specific group and provides flexibility, reusability, and ease of usage in GIS applications (Aydinoglu, 2009). 43 ISO/TC 211 Geographical Information / Geomatics Technical Committee's ISO 19103 Conceptual Schema Language and ISO 19109 Rules for Application Schema standards are used in developing a Geographical data model. Compliance with other ISO/TC 211 standards is anticipated. At the logical level, "Class Diagrams," one of the UML modeling techniques from the Geographical data model development stage, are used. At this stage, the UML definitions recommended in the ISO 19103 standard developed by the ISO/TC211 Technical Committee should be considered (Bilgin, 2013). The purpose of class diagrams in an object-oriented application is to describe the classes in the model. An object or a set of objects which share a common behavior and structure is represented by a class. A class consists of the class name, attributes, and operations. Also, restrictions, labels, and stereotypes could be included in a class. 2.9 Geography Markup Language/GML Geography Markup Language (GML), developed by OGC, is an XML application written using XML Schema for modeling, transporting, and storing geometry and attribute information of Geographical features (Alas, 2011). XML Schema files are needed to interpret XML applications. Similarly, GML Schema files are used for GML applications. Thus, users can define geographical objects (Sarı, 2014). GML was developed based on the OGC and ISO 19118 series standards. As part of this process, a standard will be established for representing information about spatial data and a grammar and dictionary for describing geographical data (CBSGM, 2012c). The basic features used by GML are derived from the definitions of OGC (Url-10). In addition, WFS, one of the OGC standards, can read and write GML files (Sarı, 2014). A GML file may contain the following concepts.  Object  Geometry  Coordinate Reference System  Time  Dynamic Object 44  Cellular Object (Geographical graphics)  Unit of Measure  Map Display Formats Although it is not necessary to have all these mentioned concepts, the object, geometry, and coordinate system are required for geographical data to be meaningful (Tunccekic & Dincer, 2007). GML documents are not affected by the method of generation. Since GML schemas are XML schemas, a single interpreter can be used for both the schema and the GML document. An application schema enforces the accurate construction of application specific GML documents by restricting and extending GML definitions. With the aid of a hierarchy of GML objects, GML defines various types and elements of XML schemas, such as features, geometries, and topologies. As described in the OGC specification, the GML objects can be broken down into several schema documents that cover such topics as Feature, Geometry, Topology, Value, Coverage, Temporal, Coordinate Reference System, XLink, and StyleDescriptor. There are also subtypes of Feature, such as Observation, Coverage, and Definition. As a result, the application schema applies the necessary features and types to the particular domain. Examples of GML documents and schema documents can be found in the OGC